Underwater Acoustic Characterisation Of Unexploded Ordnance - Disposal Using Deflagration
The practical acoustic characterisation of deflagration involves not just measuring pressure, but also derived metrics relevant to environmental regulation. Key metrics include Sound Exposure Level (SEL), which integrates the total acoustic energy over time, and peak-to-peak pressure. For a detonation, the SEL is concentrated in a few milliseconds; for deflagration, the same or lower total energy is spread over a longer duration. This results in a lower instantaneous peak pressure but a potentially comparable cumulative SEL at close range. Therefore, a comprehensive characterisation must assess the risk of behavioural disturbance (e.g., avoidance of feeding grounds) versus physical injury. Studies using caged fish and acoustic tags have shown that while fish may startle at the onset of deflagration, they rarely exhibit the lethal barotrauma (swim bladder rupture) common after detonations.
The legacy of past conflicts and military training exercises is a hidden hazard lying silent on the seabed: unexploded ordnance (UXO). Millions of tons of shells, bombs, and mines contaminate marine environments worldwide, posing significant risks to human safety, offshore construction (e.g., wind farms, pipelines), and marine ecosystems. Traditional disposal methods, such as high-order detonation using donor charges, are effective but increasingly controversial. They generate intense shockwaves, devastating acoustic trauma to marine mammals, fish, and invertebrates. In response, the defence and environmental communities have turned to low-order deflagration—a rapid, controlled burning rather than a supersonic explosion. However, to validate deflagration as a viable, quieter alternative, a rigorous underwater acoustic characterisation is essential. This essay argues that the acoustic signature of deflagration is fundamentally distinct from that of detonation, characterised by lower peak pressures, a shift in energy to lower frequencies, and a longer rise time, making it a potentially transformative but still challenging technology for UXO disposal. This results in a lower instantaneous peak pressure
To understand the acoustic benefits of deflagration, one must first contrast it with the physics of detonation. A high-order detonation involves a supersonic reaction front that generates a discontinuous pressure wave—a shock. In water, which is nearly incompressible, this shock propagates with devastating efficiency. The key acoustic parameters of a detonation are extremely high peak pressure (often exceeding 200 dB re 1µPa at 1m), a very short rise time (microseconds), and a high-amplitude, broad-frequency spectrum extending into ultrasonic ranges. This impulsive sound is particularly harmful to marine life, causing barotrauma (tissue damage from pressure changes), temporary or permanent hearing loss, and behavioural disruption over vast areas (tens of kilometres). The legacy of past conflicts and military training
